Thanks for all the help/suggestions. It appears DVAP has a 61 NYer fender with no rust Arizona sheetmetal. Just have to plug the holes for trim at the body shop.
Interestingly, when I told him to look for either 61 or 62 NYer fender (long wheel base), he came back and said his books list the 61 and 62 NYer fenders as not interchangeable. I would have sworn they were the same. Am I missing something, or is his info not right?
I had a 62 NYer station wagon and a 61 NYer 8 door limo, and would have sworn they had the same nose/fenders. In fact, I believe the 62 NYer wagon was actually made up of three cars by Chrysler that year: A 61 NYer nose, 62 4-door hdtp dog house, and 61 Plymouth station wagon rear quarters (just different tail lights bolted on)?